Location
Taste
8.8
Value
8.5
Discovery
7.5
Authenticity
8.5
Local confidence
8.0
Andrew Edmunds is an independent Modern European room in Soho that still reads as a find — not on the tourist circuit, and the kind of place a local would send you.
Why we recommend
Candlelit Lexington Street basement — chalkboard menu, romantic without being stuffy, and one of Soho's best-kept sit-down secrets. Feels discovered even though it's been here for decades.
Standout orders
Delicious, traditional European cooking, with a frequently changing handwritten menu that offers unique twists and vegetarian options
Atmosphere & service
Exceptional and reasonably priced wine list, as well as the intimate, cozy, and timeless atmosphere
Atmosphere & service
Staff are attentive, knowledgeable, and provide excellent service
What to order
Seasonal chalkboard menu
Our pickCandlelit Lexington Street basement — chalkboard menu, romantic without being stuffy, and one of Soho's best-kept sit-down secrets.
Wine by the glass
Our pickDrink from the list, not just the food — glasses here are half the reason to come.
Cheese
Our pickA curator staple at Andrew Edmunds — the dish we'd send a first-timer toward.
Daily fish
Our pickAsk what landed today — the kitchen rotates this based on what's best in season.
Good for
Practical notes
Chalkboard changes daily — go with what's fresh. Intimate room.
Been here?